Rayner Spencer Mills Research Limited
Menu
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Advisers
    • Ratings
  • Managed Portfolio Service
  • Providers
  • Investors
    • Fund Rating
  • The Hub
  • Conferences
    • Past Events
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Login to the RSMR Hub

Investors

Here at RSMR we have a dedicated team of experienced people who carry out research on a wide range of funds.

Fund ratings - what’s really behind them?

The fund industry has several agencies which analyse funds and rate them, or their manager, based on the fund’s performance prospects - but what happens in the ratings process?

Ratings are often used by financial advisers when they choose funds for their clients and can also be a useful indicator for investors’ own decisions. Part of our work analyses fund performance and associated risks then makes a predictive assessment after a detailed discussion with the fund manager. Others rely solely on the past performance while we focus on the ability of the manager to perform in future. Here’s how we go about it.

Preparation

Fund manager meetings are central to rating funds. They improve understanding of the fund, how it operates and enable us to ask the questions that investors want answers to – rather than those that fund managers prefer to answer. Preparation for these meetings is crucial. The questions must be practical, insightful, timely and focus on important areas of fund management and performance.

How long have you been doing this?

Gaining an understanding of the fund manager’s career background is crucial, including why they were attracted to fund management and their previous roles.

Style and motivation

As well as assessing the lead manager’s performance, we ask about their team’s track record.  This helps us understand the fund manager’s style and motivations and if they have a passion for the job. We also find out about their other responsibilities and how much time they devote to the fund in question.

Investment objective

We ask what the manager believes they can achieve with their portfolio as this reveals the fund’s real investment objective which could differ from many of its peers.

Why size matters

Liquidity – the level of buying, selling and the associated costs - can affect a fund’s performance, especially if it invests in smaller companies or less fluid markets. We establish the size of the fund and total monies invested. If the Assets Under Management (AUM) is too large, the fund may lose the advantage of being nimble.

Spot the weaknesses

When considering performance, it’s necessary to scrutinise the longer-term strategy on an annual basis. This helps to identify if the manager has a strong style bias, or if particular market or economic conditions suit how money is managed. It will also reveal if a fund has consistently performed better than its benchmark index, or has simply benefitted from one or two strong years’ performance. This helps us understand if and when the fund might struggle. Use of currency hedging could also exaggerate a fund’s performance so it appears far better, or worse, than would otherwise be the case.

Who does what?

We find out how the investment team’s responsibilities are allocated, and how this fits with research and portfolio construction. We also ask how long the process has been in place as this will demonstrate if it has been tempered through an economic cycle.

What’s the real plan?

Discovering a fund manager’s objectives is crucial. Targeted alpha, an investment’s performance against its market index, can vary between country and sector and individual company stock selection. We establish what the manager considers important in individual businesses. This includes finding out what their selling discipline is as many find selling harder than buying. Some portfolio managers are prepared to hold cash for allocation to assets, while others prefer to be fully invested.  In each case, we ask what  they believe their competitive edge is.

Risks

Both formal and informal risk management systems are examined. Risk controls can exist at country, sector, stock or market capitalisation levels, or they may cross different asset classes and sectors. It is also important to establish whether managers apply tracking error or VAR (Value at Risk). Investors can do their own ‘common sense’ check by looking at minimum/maximum stock positions or seeing if leverage is used in portfolio construction.

Why did you buy that stock?

We focus on a manager’s current strategy and the types of investment positions held in the portfolio and then check that these fit within the central aims. It is also interesting to check if the fund’s worst performers during the last 12 months are still held, and if so, why.

Fund turnover

Fund turnover costs money, but some managers can implement highly-successful trading strategies to offset this. However, if turnover shoots up when a manager is underperforming, it can be a sign of indecision and herald further underperformance.

The approach detailed above enables us to judge if we should rate a fund or not. We are thorough because in doing so, we put our name to a fund, and with that, our reputation.

About the author

Geoff Mills has worked in financial services for more than 40 years. In 2004, he, along with Ken Rayner and Caroline Spencer, established RSMR, which is now among the UK’s best-respected fund rating agencies.

Investor Insight Newsletter

* indicates required

What our clients say

Tim Sargisson | Sandringham Financial Partners

"Geoff and the team are a pleasure to work with. Their approach has allowed Sandringham to develop a great partnership with RSMR in the two to three years we have worked together. Their knowledge, attention to detail, coupled with a clear understanding of the intermediary market has been invaluable in allowing us to develop a robust investment proposition which appeals to both our Partners and clients. I have no hesitation in recommending RSMR to any firm looking to develop investment services to deliver the best outcomes for clients."

Tim Sargisson | Sandringham Financial Partners
Chief Executive Officer

Derek B. Stewart | Strategic Asset Managers Ltd

"RSMR have played a central role in the design and management of our model portfolios. The team are not only helpful but also accessible when required. They are a key “partner” in our business and work closely in helping us deliver a leading solution to our clients."

Derek B. Stewart | Strategic Asset Managers Ltd.
Chief Executive

Jeremy Woodley | FPFS CFP Chartered MCSI

"The Fry Group have been working on a bespoke basis with RSMR for some 4 years. They have certainly helped us deliver a more rigorous and detailed look at the fund marketplace and at better cost than trying to build it ourselves. We also know from our data it has led to better client outcomes. We would happily recommend them as a way of providing enhanced due diligence in the fund space."

Jeremy Woodley | FPFS CFP Chartered MCSI
Managing Director, The Fry Group

Mike Seddon APFS | Chartered Financial Planner

"Grayside first started working with RSMR in 2010, when we moved from fund picking to a centralised investment proposition. The team has never been more than a phone call or email away and on several occasions, they’ve obliged with meetings in our office or London. Portfolio allocation reports are well presented, concise, expertly researched and written. I have recommended RSMR to a number of peers over the last 9 years and would have no hesitation in doing so again."

Mike Seddon APFS | Chartered Financial Planner
Managing Director

RSMR Group

Number 20, Ryefield Business Park Belton Road, Silsden BD20 0EE.

Rayner Spencer Mills Research Limited is a limited company registered in England and Wales under Company Registration Number 5227656. Registered Office at Number 20, Ryefield Business Park, Belton Road, Silsden, West Yorkshire, BD20 0EE. RSMR is a registered Trademark.

Copyright © 2021 Rayner Spencer Mills Research Limited. All rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | Cookies Policy

Events

We participate in a number of events to support our advisory clients and the market generally.

Our own flagship event, the RSMR Investment Conference and R Awards, is held each year in Yorkshire.

Full details of past & future events can be found at www.RAwards.co.uk

 

Contact Us

Get In Touch

For more information call 01535 656 555 or email enquiries@rsmr.co.uk

or write to us at:

Number 20
Ryefield Business Park
Belton Road
Silsden BD20 0EE

Cookie Policy

Cookies are used on our site to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we’ll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies on our website.

Some cookies are essential so you can move around the website and use its features. Without these cookies, some services you've asked for can't be provided. These cookies don't gather information about you that could be used for marketing or remembering where you've been on the internet.

What are cookies and how do they work?

Cookies are small bits of text that are downloaded to your computer or mobile device when you visit a website. Your browser sends these cookies back to the website every time you visit the site again, so it can recognise you and can then tailor what you see on the screen.

Some of the cookies we use

Certain cookies are necessary in order for you to use our websites. These are used 'in-session' each time you visit and then expire when you leave the site. They’re not stored on your computer and they don't contain any personal data. However, you can delete them via your browser if you wish to, but this will restrict the functions that you're able to carry out on our sites.

Session cookies

These enable you to carry out some essential functions on our sites, such as maintaining log in details for the session or a transaction. They also help by minimising the need to transfer information across the internet. They are not stored on your computer and they expire when you terminate your browser session or logout of certain areas.

Secure cookie

A secure cookie is only used when a browser is visiting a server via HTTPS, ensuring that the cookie is always encrypted when transmitting from client to server. This makes the cookie less likely to be exposed to cookie theft via eavesdropping.

Persistent cookies

These are used to persist a user's preference across e.g. setting items such as the open status of the carousel, and remain until the expiry date and time set by the web server (or otherwise manually deleted by the user).

Analytics

We like to keep track of what pages and links are popular and which ones don't get used so much to help us keep our sites relevant and up to date. It's also very useful to be able to identify trends of how people navigate (find their way through) our sites and help us provide a more friendly solution.

Third-party cookie

Google Analytics tracking (and most web tracking software) uses cookies in order to provide meaningful reports about site visitors. However, Google Analytics cookies do not collect personal data about website visitors.

Managing your cookies

You’ll find more information about cookies at www.allaboutcookies.org, which gives details on how to delete cookies from your computer. For information on how to do this on your mobile phone browser, please see your handset manual.